Using “Beef on Dairy” is having a major impact on the structure and economics of dairy herds. As a shortage of beef started in 2020, it created an opportunity for expansion of “Beef on Dairy”. Currently, more than 60% of U.S. dairy herds are using “Beef on Dairy” to improve finances. Typically, 30% of the herd is inseminated with Angus bull semen. The remaining 70% of the herd is typically inseminated with Holstein sexed semen. This post will cover some of the details on this change in dairy management. The data used is generalized and there are variances among herds.
WHY ARE ONLY 30% OF THE HERD TYPICALLY INSEMINATED WITH ANGUS BULL SEMEN?
The dairy farm must maintain the number of cows used for milk. To maintain the size of the herd, Holstein female calves are needed. Sexed semen is used in the 70% of the herd to get the most female calves for replacements.
Efforts are ongoing to increase the percent of cows producing “Beef on Dairy”.
DO THE 30% OF MILK COWS INSEMINATED WITH ANGUS BULL SEMEN PRODUCE A SMALLER AMOUNT OF MILK?
There is very little difference in the volume of milk based on the type of semen used.
IS THE BEEF FROM A DAIRY CALF AS GOOD AS BEEF FROM A BEEF HERD?
The very best meat still comes from beef herds, but the “Beef on Dairy” calves are becoming competitive and the quality keeps improving.
WHICH COWS ARE SELECTED FOR GETTING THE ANGUS (OR OTHER) BULL SEMEN?
Typically, the older and lower producing cows are selected for bull semen. The higher producing Holsteins are used to produce the highest producing Holstein replacement calves.
ARE “BEEF ON DAIRY” CALVES REACHING MARKET MATURITY WITH LESS FEED AND FEWER DAYS THAN HOLSTEIN CALVES?
“Beef on Dairy” calves require approximately 250 days to meet the weight needed for slaughter. Holstein calves need up to 50 additional days to reach the same finish. With fewer days, there are significant savings in feed and housing expenses.
WILL THE NEED FOR “BEEF ON DAIRY” CONTINUE?
“Beef on Dairy” is less expensive to make than beef from a beef herd. Even if prices and availability from beef herds decrease, there is still an opportunity for “Beef on Dairy”.
HOW SIGNIFICANT IS THE ECONOMIC IMPACT FROM “BEEF ON DAIRY”?
The value of “Beef on Dairy” calves is typically estimated at $1,500 per calf. If the cows used for “Beef on Dairy” produce 25,000 pounds per lactation, the extra revenue from the calf would be about $5 per cwt. for the “Beef on Dairy” cows. If they represent 30% of the herd, that will average $1.50 per cow per cwt. in the herd. If the percent of “Beef on Dairy” cows went to 40%, that would average $2.00 per cwt. If 65% of the herd was “Beef on Dairy”, that would average $3.25 per cwt. Expanding the “Beef on Dairy” has a very significant impact.
HOW WILL THIS IMPACT SMALLER HERDS?
Adding “Beef on Dairy” to a herd adds complexity and requires management. While it is an excellent tool for large herds, it is difficult for small herds. This will accelerate the decrease in small farms. The low prices for protein in Class III milk demand another source of revenue to remain financially stable.